Gregg's Diet Shack
  • Journey
    • My Health >
      • Genome
      • ACC Fight
    • Chris' Journey
    • About me >
      • Personality
      • Politics
  • Index
  • Basics
    • Discussions by Subject >
      • A-I >
        • Acidity
        • Agriculture
        • Anti-nutrients
        • Antioxidants
        • Brain - Key to Keto-Adaptation
        • Carnivory >
          • Carnivore Science Video
          • My Carnivore Experiment Lecture
        • Cholesterol
        • CICO
        • Coffee
        • Dental >
          • Dental Caries and Carbohydrates
        • Deuterium
        • Dietary vs Liver made fats
        • Fiber >
          • Fiber Menace
        • Gluten
        • Honey
        • Immunity
        • Insulin Resistance
      • J-Z >
        • Ketosis
        • Light and Health
        • Methylation
        • Mitochondria
        • Nutrients >
          • Minerals
          • Carbohydrate >
            • Glucose
          • Fat >
            • Saturated Fat
          • Protein >
            • Protein Leverage Hypothesis
          • Nutrients - Plant vs Animal Sources
          • Potassium
        • Obesity
        • Salt gets its own page
        • Soy - Western A. Price
        • Statins
        • Uric Acid
        • Vaccines
        • Vegetarianism >
          • Vegetarians Have Smaller Brains
        • Vitamins >
          • D
          • Vitamin C
          • Vitamin D >
            • Covid19-D
            • Slides from Garland's Lecture
          • Vitamin K
    • Foods - Nobody does it better than Georgia Ede >
      • Arachidonic Acid
      • Beef >
        • Red meat - health concerns
      • Meat Composition
      • Vegetables
    • The People >
      • Vilhjálmur Stefánnson
      • Benjamin Bikman
      • Ivor Cummins
      • Georgia Ede MD
      • Phil Escott >
        • Arthritis: The Best Thing That Happened To Me
        • Pure Activity
      • Duane Graveline (SpaceDoc)
      • Barry Groves >
        • Do You Have to be Mental to be a Vegetarian
      • Zoe Harcombe
      • Adele Hite
      • Lierre Keith
      • Hugh Khan
      • Malcolm Kendrick
      • Paul Mabry
      • Malaena Medford >
        • MM On Calories
        • MM On Cancer
        • MM on Covid
        • MM On Feeding Our Young
        • MM On Histamine
        • MM On Ketosis
        • MM On Peanuts
        • MM On Raw Food
        • MM On Sustainability of Food
      • Tom Naughton - Fat Head
      • Tim Noakes
      • L. Amber O'Hearn
      • The Bear - Owsley Stanley
    • Rosedale Lecture
    • All Sorts of Links and Videos
    • The 20 Myths
    • Diet and Nutrition for the Australian People
    • Diet, Nutrition and Biochemistry Blogs and Websites
    • Discussion on the 'life expectancy' myth
    • Micronutrients Veg vs. Meat
    • Human History >
      • Articles
      • Catching Fire
      • How Carnivorous are we
    • The Fat of the Land
  • Diseases
    • Aging
    • Arthritis
    • Cancer >
      • Cancer as a Metabolic Disease
      • Cancer - General
      • Cancer - Breast
      • Cancer - Colon >
        • Cancer - Colorectal (links)
      • Cancer - Pancreatic
      • Cancer Skin >
        • Cancer - Skin - SecondOpinions
      • Carbohydrate and Cancer
    • Covid19 >
      • Antivirals
      • Chetty
      • Covidvax
      • Mask
    • Cramp
    • Dementia
    • Diabetes
    • Diverticulosis >
      • Diverticular Disease Information - Barry Groves
    • Fatty Liver
    • Gallstones
    • Gout
    • Heart Disease
    • Kidney Stones
    • Psychological
    • Scurvy
    • Ulcerative Colitis
  • The Studies
    • Of mice and men
    • Links to Studies (and Other Knowledge)
    • The Study
    • Uffe Ravnskof Commentary
    • 8 Glasses of Water a Day?
    • Simple Facts
    • To Microwave or Not to Microwave
    • Social Stuff >
      • Political Party Policies On Food Guidelines
    • Gun Stuff >
      • Shooting
    • Climate Science >
      • 97%
      • David Kear Booklet
      • 31000
      • Gerlach-1991
      • Alarmist Claim Rebuttals
  • Tools
    • Non Diet Tools
  • Blog
    • BUPA >
      • Bupa "Consultation" Documents
    • Greggatshack's Wordpress Blogs
    • Blogs from Malaena Medford
    • Various and Sundry >
      • My Session with Savelev >
        • Steak
      • My Session With Blocked By Pete Evans
      • Fencing Manual
      • Vic Stone and I on handicapping
      • Betty Megaw
      • Chris Genealogy Test
  • Quotes
  • Recipes
  • Articles
    • 42
    • The Cure for Diabetes - Men's Health
  • Contact
  • RDA
    • A-Z of Food
  • Liver Flush
  • Smacking
  • Controversy
    • Controversy-Kathleen
    • SatFat
    • WTFWR
    • Unvaxxed
  • Whisky
  • Lentils
  • Chad
  • IQ
  • False
  • Falseinfo
  • factcheckgood
  • factcheckivermectin
  • TGC-Licence
  • Moccasins
  • totalgym
    • Totalgym - Terms
    • totalgym 1-9
    • Totalgym 10-19
    • Totalgym 20-29
    • Totalgym 30-
    • Totalgym-Additional

Carnivory

Picture
Two Carnivores, Tiakarete and Me

By definition, I'm a hypercarnivore, which means I get more than 70% of my food as meat from animals. I realise that this is a choice I have made, however it is based on knowledge and data I've found which shows that humans do well on a meat-based diet and not so well on a plant-based one. This is mostly based on the largest observational study we have available to us - 2.5 million years long and comprising all of the human species, past and present. 

It is my assertion that the move from eating fruit to eating meat was what enabled our brain to become larger and our gut to become smaller. More recent history has shown that our brains have become smaller and our gut is becoming larger. Most of the modern diseases of dental decay, diabetes, dementia, cancer and coronary, along with our waistline, are all increasing with our increased reliance on plants in our diet. 

I've been recovering my health in my sixties by reducing plants in my diet from 2013 and going fully animal-based food only since April 2014. 
Carnivores may alternatively be classified according to the percentage of meat in their diet. The diet of a hypercarnivore consists of more than 70% meat, that of a mesocarnivore 50–70%, and that of a hypocarnivoreless than 30%, with the balance consisting of non-animal foods such as fruits, other plant material, or fungi. (Wikipedia: Carnivore)

The Ultimate Guide to the Carnivore Diet - L. Amber O'Hearn and Raphael Sirtoli
"This is truly great. Well researched, clear, accessible, and convincing without seeming preachy or arrogant." - Zoë Jacobs

A Couple of Closed Facebook Groups that I am Involved With
If you are curious about carnivory and want to ask some questions, click on the links and join up. 
Principia Carnivora
100% Carnivore and Beyond

Exceptionally high δ15N values in collagen single amino acids confirm Neandertals as high-trophic level carnivores
"Compound-specific isotope analyses are a very promising method for reconstructing aspects of past diets, especially by combining nitrogen and carbon isotope analyses on single amino acids to clearly distinguish aquatic and terrestrial sources of proteins, and to estimate with more precision the contribution of plants in individual diets. Our application of CSIA to two Neandertals has shown that both were high trophic level consumers, with large herbivores being the main protein source. Therefore, there is no reason to invoke myriad dietary interpretations such as the consumption of mushrooms, putrid animal flesh, mammoths, or freshwater fish to explain their high bulk bone collagen nitrogen isotope values of Neandertals in relation to carnivores from the same site. However, we acknowledge that our isotopic study does not rule out the occasional consumption of these foods. Instead, the differing high N values between Neandertals and associated carnivores is likely due to the consumption of different herbivores from different environments. When we conduct CSIA, which is not environmentally baseline sensitive like bulk collagen N values, Neandertals and carnivores clearly are at the same trophic level."
  • Neanderthals' main food source was definitely meat
  • Stable isotopes reveal patterns of diet and mobility in the last Neandertals and first modern humans in Europe​

​Carnivore Diet: Are Humans Carnivores?
​Cecum – to me this is the biggest nail in the coffin for anyone who thinks we should eat a lot of plants. The cecum is filled with bacteria and enzymes, that digest cellulose aka plant cell walls. It is a vital to herbivores and ranges in importance in Omnivores. Humans have a cecum, however it is now just an empty sac, basically just an extension of the large intestines and no further digestion takes part in the cecum. So we had a cecum that is vital for plant digestion, however we evolved to not use it. This is huge because humans probably have the greatest survival instinct ever, so to get rid of something that could have helped us survive shows how little we came value plants in our diet over millions of years.
Picture

Carnivore Diet: Why would it work? What about nutrients and fiber?
Great little video covering most people's questions about the 'maximal elimination diet'.
Only 20 minutes - well worth the time. 

A couple of good Facebook communities specialising in carnivory
  • Principia Carnivora - Closed group - you have to ask to join, but should have no problem. Just over 19,000 members as of August 2018
  • 100% Carnivore and Beyond - Closed group - UK based, you require a broad sense of Brit-like humour if you wish to join and not be offended. Just over 4,000 members at August 2018. 

Esmée La Fleur has created a great website with interviews, testimonials and articles on aspects of zero carb living at Zero Carb Zen
Picture
Esmée and Sasha

A good little primer on carnivory
Carnivore Diet 101: My Experience + Q&A
​Camille Julia

​No, not omnivore... The "Carnivore Diet," aka: 100% animal-product diet. Goodbye chocolate, goodbye adaptogens, goodbye green vegetables. 

Crazy? Kind of. But this extreme counter-diet to veganism is changing people's lives for the better across world, completely breaking our collective preconceived notions of what it means to be healthy. I am striving to live a long and thriving life, and always looking for ways to break my own beliefs in the name of a greater truth... so I lit up at the opportunity to share my own personal experience with such a mind-boggling trend. It goes against some of the core principles I believe personally when it comes to health, and so I can think of no better way to get to the bottom of this than to just try it myself!

Don't You Find Just Eating Meat Boring?
Phil Escott on the subject - British fisherman, family man, writer and drummer who cured himself of severe, debilitating autoimmune illness by changing to carnivore way of eating. His book - Arthritis; The best thing that ever happened to me.

​​ESQUIMO TEETH PROVE HEALTH OF MEAT DIET
​By means of some 90 models of Eskimo teeth, Dr. Adelbert Fernald, Curator of the Harvard Dental School Museum, has proved that eating a strictly meat diet is the ideal way in which to keep the human mouth in a healthy condition, and that it is due to the fact that civilized people do not eat enough meat that they as a rule have decayed teeth.

An excellent video condensing almost all of the science I've discovered in support of the carnivore (plant-free) way of living I've been experimenting with over the last 5 years. 

Just Eat Meat
Comprehensive list of resources for people on meat heavy diets. ​Created by Michael Goldstein (@bitstein)

Meat Heals Website 
A list of testimonies from people who have found that meat has cured them of a variety of debilitating conditions. Search by condition down the sidebar. 

Barry Groves discusses the biology of humans

How carnivorous are we? The implication for protein consumption
Miki Ben-Dor
Summary by Jennifer Lechner
  1. The average size of mammals fell dramatically between the Pleistocene (about 2 million years ago) and the current era. The author argues that this happened due to hunting by humans.
  2. The diversity of those large mammalian species has been drastically reduced, leaving current hunter-gatherers in a much different environment than what once existed.
  3. The larger the animals, the more likely they were to go extinct during this period.
  4. Studying weaning patterns, carnivores, omnivores, and herbivores have their own distinct timetables. Humans land squarely in the carnivore category.
  5. Carnivores' fat cells are small and numerous. Omnivores have fewer, larger fat cells. "Humans were found to be at the top of the carnivorous pattern."
  6. The stomach acidity of an omnivore averages 2.9, a carnivore 2.2, and a scavenger 1.3. Human stomach acidity is 1.5.
  7. Other primates have much larger guts than we do, especially regarding the large intestine, which digests fiber. They all have longer large intestines than small intestines. So do pigs, famous omnivores.
  8. We are also adapted for endurance running, throwing, and going long periods without eating, all of which point toward life as a hunter of large game.

The evolution of the human trophic level during the Pleistocene 
Miki Ben-Dor, Raphael Sirtoli, Ran Barkai
First published: 05 March 2021
Abstract:
The human trophic level (HTL) during the Pleistocene and its degree of variability serve, explicitly or tacitly, as the basis of many explanations for human evolution, behavior, and culture. Previous attempts to reconstruct the HTL have relied heavily on an analogy with recent hunter-gatherer groups' diets. In addition to technological differences, recent findings of substantial ecological differences between the Pleistocene and the Anthropocene cast doubt regarding that analogy's validity. Surprisingly little systematic evolution-guided evidence served to reconstruct HTL. Here, we reconstruct the HTL during the Pleistocene by reviewing evidence for the impact of the HTL on the biological, ecological, and behavioral systems derived from various existing studies. We adapt a paleobiological and paleoecological approach, including evidence from human physiology and genetics, archaeology, paleontology, and zoology, and identified 25 sources of evidence in total. The evidence shows that the trophic level of the Homo lineage that most probably led to modern humans evolved from a low base to a high, carnivorous position during the Pleistocene, beginning with Homo habilis and peaking in Homo erectus. A reversal of that trend appears in the Upper Paleolithic, strengthening in the Mesolithic/Epipaleolithic and Neolithic, and culminating with the advent of agriculture. We conclude that it is possible to reach a credible reconstruction of the HTL without relying on a simple analogy with recent hunter-gatherers' diets. The memory of an adaptation to a trophic level that is embedded in modern humans' biology in the form of genetics, metabolism, and morphology is a fruitful line of investigation of past HTLs, whose potential we have only started to explore.

Humans are Carnivores
​
Kevin MacPhee
So are we even omnivores? We have the survival capabilities to live off of plants for years and even decades, but that hardly means we should be eating them instead of meat. We didn’t just evolve to eat meat, we evolved because we ate meat. The industrial revolution has only harmed our bodies and health. It is clear that eating mainly meat is what allowed humans to flourish over 2.5 millions years. There is no nutrition in plant foods that cannot be found in animals, but the same cannot be said for plants. If we continue to eat plant-based diets, our brains will continue to shrink, our gut will expand, and eventually we will find ourselves amongst the monkeys in the jungles like 2.5 million years ago.

WHAT HUMANS EVOLVED TO EAT
Carnivore Diet Coach
​So, what did we really evolve to eat? The trend is clear. We have become more equipped to eat meat-based diets and less equipped to consume plant-based diets. We started out as a species that solely ate plants, but that changed due to the myriad factors listed and discussed above.

We’re talking about thousands of years of evolution and a lot changes in that time. We’ve become better hunters, which led to us becoming better suited to eating meat and our bodies became less adept at consuming plants. Focusing solely on plants and ignoring meat leads to poor nutrition and contributes to disease.

The bottom line is that humans evolved to eat meat, and that’s one of the reasons why so many people are now turning to the carnivore diet and finding real success with it. If you want to find out more about it and try it for yourself, simply make the most of the online carnivore diet coaching we offer.

Keto Diet in Human Evolution

Gut bacteria associated with animal-based diet may mitigate risk of cardiovascular disease
  • "The data we reviewed show significantly more Bilophila in the microbiomes of healthy people compared to those with cardiovascular disease, and that Bilophila numbers go up in response to a diet based on meat compared to a plant-based diet," Kivenson said. "Our findings suggest Bilophila's role in the microbiome and human health might depend on the specific context and that their potential as a probiotic that mitigates animal products' role in heart disease should be studied further."

​Meat and mental health: A meta-analysis of meat consumption, depression, and anxiety
​The purpose of this meta-analysis was to extend our previous systematic review (Dobersek et al. 2020) and provide quantitative evidence to inform clinicians, policy-makers, and future research. Our results show that meat abstention (vegetarianism or veganism) is clearly associated with poorer mental health, specifically higher levels of both depression and anxiety. Our cumulative analyses suggest that the more rigorous the study, the stronger the relation between meat abstention and mental illness. However, the current body of evidence preludes temporal and causal inferences, and none should be inferred.

Picture

Picture

Picture
Meat consumption per capita vs human stunted growth rates
Picture
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Journey
    • My Health >
      • Genome
      • ACC Fight
    • Chris' Journey
    • About me >
      • Personality
      • Politics
  • Index
  • Basics
    • Discussions by Subject >
      • A-I >
        • Acidity
        • Agriculture
        • Anti-nutrients
        • Antioxidants
        • Brain - Key to Keto-Adaptation
        • Carnivory >
          • Carnivore Science Video
          • My Carnivore Experiment Lecture
        • Cholesterol
        • CICO
        • Coffee
        • Dental >
          • Dental Caries and Carbohydrates
        • Deuterium
        • Dietary vs Liver made fats
        • Fiber >
          • Fiber Menace
        • Gluten
        • Honey
        • Immunity
        • Insulin Resistance
      • J-Z >
        • Ketosis
        • Light and Health
        • Methylation
        • Mitochondria
        • Nutrients >
          • Minerals
          • Carbohydrate >
            • Glucose
          • Fat >
            • Saturated Fat
          • Protein >
            • Protein Leverage Hypothesis
          • Nutrients - Plant vs Animal Sources
          • Potassium
        • Obesity
        • Salt gets its own page
        • Soy - Western A. Price
        • Statins
        • Uric Acid
        • Vaccines
        • Vegetarianism >
          • Vegetarians Have Smaller Brains
        • Vitamins >
          • D
          • Vitamin C
          • Vitamin D >
            • Covid19-D
            • Slides from Garland's Lecture
          • Vitamin K
    • Foods - Nobody does it better than Georgia Ede >
      • Arachidonic Acid
      • Beef >
        • Red meat - health concerns
      • Meat Composition
      • Vegetables
    • The People >
      • Vilhjálmur Stefánnson
      • Benjamin Bikman
      • Ivor Cummins
      • Georgia Ede MD
      • Phil Escott >
        • Arthritis: The Best Thing That Happened To Me
        • Pure Activity
      • Duane Graveline (SpaceDoc)
      • Barry Groves >
        • Do You Have to be Mental to be a Vegetarian
      • Zoe Harcombe
      • Adele Hite
      • Lierre Keith
      • Hugh Khan
      • Malcolm Kendrick
      • Paul Mabry
      • Malaena Medford >
        • MM On Calories
        • MM On Cancer
        • MM on Covid
        • MM On Feeding Our Young
        • MM On Histamine
        • MM On Ketosis
        • MM On Peanuts
        • MM On Raw Food
        • MM On Sustainability of Food
      • Tom Naughton - Fat Head
      • Tim Noakes
      • L. Amber O'Hearn
      • The Bear - Owsley Stanley
    • Rosedale Lecture
    • All Sorts of Links and Videos
    • The 20 Myths
    • Diet and Nutrition for the Australian People
    • Diet, Nutrition and Biochemistry Blogs and Websites
    • Discussion on the 'life expectancy' myth
    • Micronutrients Veg vs. Meat
    • Human History >
      • Articles
      • Catching Fire
      • How Carnivorous are we
    • The Fat of the Land
  • Diseases
    • Aging
    • Arthritis
    • Cancer >
      • Cancer as a Metabolic Disease
      • Cancer - General
      • Cancer - Breast
      • Cancer - Colon >
        • Cancer - Colorectal (links)
      • Cancer - Pancreatic
      • Cancer Skin >
        • Cancer - Skin - SecondOpinions
      • Carbohydrate and Cancer
    • Covid19 >
      • Antivirals
      • Chetty
      • Covidvax
      • Mask
    • Cramp
    • Dementia
    • Diabetes
    • Diverticulosis >
      • Diverticular Disease Information - Barry Groves
    • Fatty Liver
    • Gallstones
    • Gout
    • Heart Disease
    • Kidney Stones
    • Psychological
    • Scurvy
    • Ulcerative Colitis
  • The Studies
    • Of mice and men
    • Links to Studies (and Other Knowledge)
    • The Study
    • Uffe Ravnskof Commentary
    • 8 Glasses of Water a Day?
    • Simple Facts
    • To Microwave or Not to Microwave
    • Social Stuff >
      • Political Party Policies On Food Guidelines
    • Gun Stuff >
      • Shooting
    • Climate Science >
      • 97%
      • David Kear Booklet
      • 31000
      • Gerlach-1991
      • Alarmist Claim Rebuttals
  • Tools
    • Non Diet Tools
  • Blog
    • BUPA >
      • Bupa "Consultation" Documents
    • Greggatshack's Wordpress Blogs
    • Blogs from Malaena Medford
    • Various and Sundry >
      • My Session with Savelev >
        • Steak
      • My Session With Blocked By Pete Evans
      • Fencing Manual
      • Vic Stone and I on handicapping
      • Betty Megaw
      • Chris Genealogy Test
  • Quotes
  • Recipes
  • Articles
    • 42
    • The Cure for Diabetes - Men's Health
  • Contact
  • RDA
    • A-Z of Food
  • Liver Flush
  • Smacking
  • Controversy
    • Controversy-Kathleen
    • SatFat
    • WTFWR
    • Unvaxxed
  • Whisky
  • Lentils
  • Chad
  • IQ
  • False
  • Falseinfo
  • factcheckgood
  • factcheckivermectin
  • TGC-Licence
  • Moccasins
  • totalgym
    • Totalgym - Terms
    • totalgym 1-9
    • Totalgym 10-19
    • Totalgym 20-29
    • Totalgym 30-
    • Totalgym-Additional